More Atrocities, Please
[Stupid "draft" setting. This shoulda been published yesterday.]
Yesterday, GF and I went to the National Museum of the American Indian, located in Washington DC on the mall.
(Sidebar to You Kids: "mall" has more than one meaning.)
We went with her mother, which in this case isn't a terrible thing because she (and therefore GF) have some Cherokee heritage in them, so they were especially motivated to go and find out what the folks at the Smithsonian know. We parked near the Phoenix Park Hotel, which is a pretty nice place, by the bye. I've spent a little time there. From there it was a couple of blocks' walk to the Capitol and then across the Mall to the museum itself.
Let me tell ya, this stuff looks a lot closer together than it really is.
So we get to the museum, swearing that we're going to cab it back, and in we go. Now, in our post-9/11 world, when you go to many of the museums along the Mall, you're put through a pretty extensive search. You have to empty your pockets and put the stuff on a tray, handbags get searched (they use a stick to poke around) and you have to walk through a metal detector. At this museum they did the stick search and the detector, but you didn't have to do the pockets thing. Okay, whatever.
The building itself is pretty cool (go click on the link and check it out; I'll wait here). It's meant to emulate the cliff-dwelling pueblos that some Southwestern Indians lived in (and still do, in many cases). Inside, there's a lot of empty space, though, since the atrium goes straight to the top.
One thing that I noticed was that there are not a lot of tribes represented by the museum. Some of the Southwest tribes, a few of the Pacific Northwest tribes (including those in Canada, eh), and a bunch of the South American tribes. The Seminoles of Florida got a section. A few others who I've forgotten off the top of my head.
But there was no mention of the Powhatan Tribe of Virginia, which was on-hand in Williamsburg and Jamestown. No mention of the Iroquois Indians, composed of five tribes across the Upstate New York region. No mention of the Wampanoag Indians, who greeted the Pilgrims in the 1620s. Very little mention of the Cherokees. Nothing of the Apaches, the Sioux, the Shoshones, the Hopis, the Kickapoos, Chippewas and so many others.
No mention of the Trail of Tears. No Sand Creek Massacre. No Bear River. No Chief Joseph's "I will fight no more forever." No Crazy Horse. Smallpox got a brief mention, so hurray for that, I guess.
I was disappointed. GFMom was philosophical. GF was furious. She actually went over to the Information Desk looking for a comment card so that she could complain in writing while she still had a mad going on. Apparently she met up with someone inside who told her that participation by the individual tribes is voluntary, so if you don't see a tribe represented, it's because they chose not to be represented. Furthermore, the reason that some tribes didn't participate is because they felt that the museum is a sanitized version of events, that the building is a shrine to what some have called "the lie of Manifest Destiny" and others have referred to as "the American Holocaust." Both of these are correct but the latter is more colorful.
At any rate, what's there is interesting but the whole thing really falls short. I've never been disappointed by a Smithsonian museum before this visit, and it's a real pity. GF has already stated that, as a teacher, she can't in good conscience, bring her students there for a field trip.



